Bishop Strickland urges bishops to promote Communion on the tongue and kneeling

2 hours ago 62

(LifeSiteNews) — The following is the transcript of a podcast that Bishop Joseph Strickland will soon be releasing. Addressed primarily to the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, it is entitled “Eucharistic Faith and the Responsibility of Bishops.” 

Our Lord Jesus Christ said, “This is my body.”

I want to begin there because everything I have to say today must be measured against those words. Before we consider a survey, a conference agenda, a national initiative, or a budget, we must listen to Jesus Christ. At the Last Supper, He gave the apostles His Body and Blood and commanded them to continue what He had instituted.

And in the sixth chapter of St. John’s Gospel, He said, “For my flesh is true food, and my blood is true drink.”

These words confronted His listeners with a reality they found difficult to accept. Some walked away. Jesus did not call them back by explaining that He had only meant a symbol. The difficulty of the teaching did not change its truth.

That is where we must begin, and that is where we must return.

I am recording this while here in Baltimore for the meetings of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. And I want to speak frankly about something that weighs heavily on my heart.

This week’s assembly includes two days of public business. We have an agenda, elections, committee presentations, financial matters, and votes. There are serious responsibilities involved in governing the Church, and they deserve care. But as I look at our priorities, I am dismayed that the crisis of belief in the Real Presence is not receiving the central attention I believe it demands.

To be precise, the published agenda does include an update on the International Eucharistic Congress. But an update about a congress is different from a searching examination of why so many Catholics do not believe, and whether our ordinary practices are contributing to that unbelief.

That is the examination I believe we urgently need.

A study recently reported by EWTN News found that only about 29 percent of American Catholics surveyed affirmed that the bread and wine truly become the Body and Blood of Christ. The researchers found no statistically significant improvement over the widely discussed 2019 Pew finding.

These respondents include Catholics who seldom or never attend Mass. We should be clear about that. But even among weekly Mass-goers, the reported figure was only about 60 percent.

Think about what that means. People can be present at Mass regularly and still fail to recognize the central reality of what is taking place before them.

We must take that seriously enough to examine ourselves.

I am not claiming that no one benefited from the National Eucharistic Revival. I thank God for every confession, every conversion, every hour of adoration, and every soul brought closer to Our Lord. But a national effort must also be willing to face the national evidence. The crisis remains.

When an approach has not produced the improvement we hoped for, we have a responsibility to reconsider it. And that brings me to the way we conduct our work as bishops.

There is a danger that a conference of bishops can begin to resemble a corporate board meeting, and that each bishop can begin to think of himself primarily as the chief executive officer of his diocese.

A diocese has employees, buildings, legal obligations, investments, and financial responsibilities. Someone must attend to those things. But the bishop’s identity cannot be built around managing them. We received Holy Orders. We were entrusted with the apostolic faith and the care of souls.

We are shepherds who will answer to Jesus Christ.

If administrative responsibilities fill bishops’ conversations while a crisis at the heart of the faith receives no sustained explanation, then priorities need correction. A well-organized institution can still fail in its mission. Balanced accounts cannot tell us whether our people recognize their Eucharistic Lord.

A bishop should be asking what the children in his diocese believe happens at the consecration. He should be asking whether his priests preach that truth clearly, whether Catholics understand worthy reception, and whether worship in his churches expresses adoration.

The habits of an institution can gradually shape the way its leaders think. Bishops can become accustomed to asking whether an initiative has been launched, whether a report has been delivered, and whether the planned gathering took place. Those questions tell them that work was done. However, bishops must also ask what that work has helped their flock believe and how it has helped them live.

A bishop needs people who will help him face those questions honestly. He needs priests who can speak frankly about what is happening in the parishes. He needs to listen to parents who discover that their children have completed sacramental preparation without understanding the Real Presence. He needs to hear the faithful who ask for reverent worship and feel that their concerns are dismissed.

Our meetings should help us hear those voices and accept responsibility for what they reveal. We should be able to leave a conference with a clearer understanding of how we will teach and sanctify the people entrusted to us. That is a practical test of our priorities.

The Church calls the Eucharist “the source and summit of the Christian life.” The Catechism also calls it “the sum and summary of our faith.”

The source is where the life comes from. The summit is the height toward which it is directed. Those words make a claim about the whole of Catholic life. Our schools, charitable works, evangelization, and pastoral plans must be nourished by Christ and lead people into deeper communion with Him.

When Eucharistic faith weakens, the effects reach into everything else.

The Eucharist brings us before the reality of the Incarnation. The eternal Son truly became man. He assumed a real human nature, offered Himself for our salvation, rose bodily from the dead, and gives Himself to us sacramentally.

At the consecration, the whole substance of the bread becomes His Body, and the whole substance of the wine becomes His Blood. The appearances remain. But Christ Himself is truly, really, and substantially present, whole and entire under either species: Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity.

This is transubstantiation, the change defined by the Council of Trent.

Our belief does not cause His presence. Our emotional response does not measure it. He is present because He is faithful to His word and acts through the sacramental ministry He entrusted to His Church.

The earliest Christians understood the seriousness of this.

St. Ignatius of Antioch, writing early in the second century, identified those who refused to confess that the Eucharist is the flesh of Jesus Christ, the Savior who suffered for our sins. Their rejection of His true humanity and their rejection of the Eucharist belonged together.

Later in that century, St. Justin Martyr explained that Christians did not receive the Eucharist as ordinary food and drink. They received the flesh and blood of the Incarnate Jesus.

These witnesses bring us close to the apostolic age. Eucharistic faith was already part of Christian identity. And through the centuries, the saints and popes continued to teach that faith.

In 1902, Pope Leo XIII devoted his encyclical Mirae Caritatis to the Holy Eucharist. He described the Eucharist as the “source of life.” He explained that through the sacrament Christ unites us more closely to Himself and strengthens the supernatural life He has given us.

Leo also connected Eucharistic charity with the needs of human society. Communion with Christ should bear fruit in love for one another. Worship and care for our neighbor belong together because the Lord who gives Himself to us teaches us to give ourselves.

It is worth remembering that Leo encouraged Eucharistic congresses. The question before us is whether such gatherings lead to lasting renewal in the places where Catholics actually worship.

We should judge our efforts by what they help establish in ordinary parish life.

St. Pius X likewise wanted the faithful to receive Our Lord frequently, even daily. The decree on frequent Communion approved during his pontificate insisted on the state of grace and a right intention.

It explained that we approach Communion to please God, grow in union with Him, and receive help for our weaknesses. It also called for careful preparation and appropriate thanksgiving.

That gives us an important balance. Reverence should draw properly disposed souls toward Our Lord. It should also help them understand the preparation His gift deserves.

A pastoral practice that encourages everyone to receive while rarely speaking about repentance and confession fails to communicate that balance.

St. Paul warned the Corinthians about unworthy reception and told them to examine themselves. The Church must continue to proclaim that warning with charity. A shepherd helps people recognize spiritual danger and leads them to the remedy Christ provides.

Then consider Pope Pius XII.

In his 1947 encyclical Mediator Dei, he taught that worship must be “interior as well as exterior.” We are body and soul. Our outward acts help express and form our inward dispositions.

He also warned against external observance without interior devotion. Beautiful ceremonies cannot substitute for repentance or love of God. But that does not make ceremonies unimportant. It means that our outward worship and our inward conversion must work together.

This is why I believe the conversation about Eucharistic unbelief must reach the altar.

What does a child learn by watching the adults around him at Mass? What does a newcomer conclude from the way the priest approaches the tabernacle? What do we communicate through silence, genuflection, the handling of the Sacred Host, and the manner of receiving Holy Communion?

These things are part of the formation people receive every Sunday.

A child who sees his father kneeling before the Blessed Sacrament receives a lesson before he has the vocabulary to explain it. A congregation that watches the priest take care over the smallest particles of the Sacred Host is being taught what the Church believes.

The opposite can happen as well. When sacred things are handled casually, when the sanctuary becomes a place of constant activity and conversation, people learn from that experience.

It seems we have not examined this connection honestly enough.

In the decades following Vatican II, many Catholics experienced the removal of altar rails, the widespread introduction of Communion in the hand, and the regular use of extraordinary ministers of Holy Communion.

I believe the cumulative effect of these changes has too often been a diminished sense of the sacred.

A survey cannot prove that a particular practice caused someone to lose faith. But bishops do not need to wait for a survey to ask whether our worship clearly expresses the doctrine we teach. That requires honest pastoral judgment.

I believe we should restore altar rails and actively encourage those physically able to receive Holy Communion kneeling and on the tongue. Kneeling expresses adoration with the body. It helps us acknowledge our dependence upon God. An altar rail provides a place to kneel and receive, with a moment to become still before the Lord.

Those who cannot kneel should be helped to receive reverently according to their abilities. The point is to cultivate adoration.

Another thing that I think would be helpful is ending the use of extraordinary ministers of Holy Communion and entrust its distribution entirely to ordained ministers.

I know that current discipline permits lay people to be deputed for this service. Many have served with sincere love for Christ. I am asking for a change in that discipline because I believe recovering the distinction between ordained ministry and lay service would help restore Eucharistic reverence.

St. Thomas Aquinas connected the distribution of this sacrament with the priest’s ministry and with the reverence owed to Christ’s Body. He spoke of the consecration of the priest’s hands for touching the sacrament, while recognizing exceptions in necessity.

His teaching reminds us that the manner of handling the Eucharist has theological meaning. The priest’s hands are anointed for sacred ministry. He should remember that with humility whenever he approaches the altar. His ordination imposes a responsibility to serve Christ and His people faithfully.

This brings us to another question that I believe deserves a serious hearing at a meeting of bishops.

How do we call for a renewal of Eucharistic faith while resisting the Traditional Latin Mass, whose prayers and gestures so consistently express that faith?

The restrictions introduced through Traditionis Custodes are real. They regulate where this Mass may be offered and place limits on the establishment of new groups and personal parishes. I pray those restrictions will be lifted.

I would go further. I believe the Traditional Latin Mass should be given greater prominence as a resource for renewing Eucharistic belief.

Its silence allows space for adoration. Its prayers keep the sacrificial character of the Mass before us. Its gestures of reverence and its customary manner of receiving Communion help form an awareness of the holiness that takes place.

Those who find their faith nourished there deserve pastoral care and a fair hearing.

The Novus Ordo can be celebrated with profound reverence, and countless Catholics have encountered Our Lord through it. My concern is that the Church should welcome the spiritual riches of her liturgical inheritance and allow them to bear fruit more widely.

When traditional worship is treated primarily as a difficulty to be managed, we risk overlooking something that could help address the very crisis we say we want to remedy.

We should be willing to discuss that openly. We should also be willing to discuss the scale of our national efforts.

The National Eucharistic Congress organization’s public tax filing reports approximately $17.2 million in expenses for 2024. That is the organization’s annual expense figure, rather than a complete total for every revival activity throughout the country. It is a substantial commitment of resources.

The amount alone does not establish waste. Large gatherings cost money, and the faithful who supported this effort wanted to honor Our Lord. But such spending makes an honest examination of lasting results all the more necessary.

What has changed in the average parish? Is confession more accessible? Are priests preaching the Eucharistic doctrine more clearly? Are children better prepared? Is greater care being taken with the Blessed Sacrament?

Those are questions a conference of bishops should be willing to put before itself.

There is something troubling about a Church that can mobilize resources for a major event but struggles to recover silence before Mass or provide regular opportunities for confession.

A parish does not need a national budget to teach children to genuflect. A priest does not need a convention center to explain the consecration. A bishop does not need a new committee before he can encourage adoration and reverence in his own cathedral.

These are responsibilities we can act upon now.

What happens after the gathering matters. The person who returns home must find parish life that sustains the faith awakened there. Otherwise, an extraordinary experience can remain disconnected from ordinary practice.

A Eucharistic revival must reach the altar, and it must continue there.

For that to happen, we need to recover an understanding of the Mass as sacrifice.

The sacrifice of Calvary was offered once for all. At Mass, that same sacrifice is made sacramentally present. Christ is the Priest and the Victim. Through the ministry of the ordained priest, He draws us into His offering to the Father.

The faithful participate by joining themselves to that offering. They bring their sufferings, duties, repentance, and love. Participation involves the surrender of our lives to God, including in those moments when we are silent.

That truth needs to shape the way we celebrate and the way we teach. It also needs to shape our lives outside the church.

A person can kneel beautifully and still refuse to forgive. A priest can observe the rubrics carefully and neglect prayer. We all need conversion. The reverence we show at the altar should form us in humility, chastity, honesty, and charity.

St. Francis of Assisi expressed the response Christ’s gift calls forth in his Letter to the Entire Order: “Hold back nothing of yourselves for yourselves, that He Who gives Himself totally to you may receive you totally.”

That is the generosity we should seek.

Our Lord gives Himself. We are called to answer with our lives.

For bishops, that means examining our own example before asking anything of our people. Do we make time for adoration? Do we approach the altar with recollection? Do our priests see us taking the sacramental life seriously?

A conference can help us encourage one another in those responsibilities. It can also become so absorbed in its procedures that we leave the deepest questions untouched.

I believe we need a substantial examination of Eucharistic unbelief with room for difficult questions about preaching, catechesis, confession, liturgical practice, and the example of bishops themselves.

We should be willing to hear from priests and families whose faith has been strengthened by traditional worship. We should examine whether our policies help people recognize Christ or make the path to reverent worship more difficult.

And we should leave such a discussion prepared to act.

We can begin with sustained teaching on the Real Presence, regular opportunities for confession, clear instruction about worthy Communion, and a renewed expectation of reverence in every parish.

We can recover kneeling and reception on the tongue. We can reconsider the use of extraordinary ministers and the restrictions on the Traditional Latin Mass.

These questions deserve the attention we give to budgets and administrative plans. The faith of our people is at stake.

I want to say something now to those listening who are discouraged.

You may not be able to change a conference agenda. You can still deepen Eucharistic faith in your own home. Teach your children that Jesus is truly present. Prepare for Sunday Mass. Examine your conscience. Go to confession. Spend time with Our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament.

If you struggle to believe, bring that struggle to Him honestly. Ask for faith. Seek instruction from a faithful priest. God is not offended by the sincere prayer of someone who wants to know Him more deeply.

And please pray for us bishops.

Ask Our Lord to make us faithful shepherds. Ask Him to free us from concern for status, approval, or institutional comfort when those things interfere with our duty. Ask Him to give us courage to correct our mistakes.

We will answer for the souls entrusted to us.

That thought should bring us to our knees.

Christ has given His Church a gift beyond anything we could devise or deserve. He remains with us in the Holy Eucharist. Our task is to teach that truth faithfully and order our worship and our lives around it.

As I record here in Baltimore, that is what I want to place before my brother bishops and before everyone listening.

Let us examine our priorities. Let us ask why the crisis persists. Let us be willing to change the practices that, in our judgment, have failed to nourish the faith.

The words of Our Lord remain: “This is my body.”

May our teaching, our worship, and our shepherding help His people recognize Him.

May Almighty God bless you, the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen.

Bishop Joseph E. Strickland

Bishop Emeritus

Read Entire Article