1 week ago
89
Dot Hutchison follows up her viral sensation, The Butterfly Garden, with a sequel that shifts focus while maintaining the haunting, atmospheric tension that defined the first installment. In The Roses of May, Hutchison moves away from the claustrophobic nightmare of “The Collector” to explore the lingering trauma of survivors and the relentless pursuit of a new, equally chilling predator.
The Premise
The story centers on Priya Sankar, a young woman living in the shadow of a family tragedy. Years prior, her older sister was murdered by a serial killer who targets young women and leaves them in floral displays. Priya and her mother have spent years moving from city to city, trying to outrun the grief and the terrifying possibility that the killer isn’t finished with their family.
When the killer strikes again, FBI agents Eddison, Vic, and Hanan—the team responsible for liberating the “Butterflies” in the previous book—return to the fray. Priya finds herself drawn into their investigation, becoming a bridge between the clinical world of federal profiling and the visceral reality of a victim’s life.
Key Themes and Execution
- Trauma and Resilience: Unlike many procedurals that treat victims as mere plot points, Hutchison treats the internal lives of survivors with significant weight. The novel explores how trauma isn’t just an event, but a persistent environment that dictates how one moves through the world.
- The Dynamics of the FBI Team: The camaraderie between Eddison, Vic, and Hanan provides a necessary groundedness to the story. Their protective, almost paternal relationship with Priya adds emotional stakes that go beyond solving a “whodunit.”
- Pacing and Atmosphere: The prose is lyrical yet sharp. Hutchison excels at creating a sense of “quiet dread”—the feeling that even in a sunny garden or a suburban home, something is fundamentally wrong.
Critical Takeaway
While The Butterfly Garden relied on a high-concept, shocking hook, The Roses of May is a more traditional investigative thriller. Some readers may find it less “explosive” than the first book, but it succeeds as a character study. Priya is a compelling protagonist; she is prickly, guarded, and fiercely intelligent, making her a refreshing departure from the “damsel in distress” trope.
Final Verdict: A somber, well-paced sequel that honors the survivors of the first book while carving out its own identity. It is a must-read for those who prefer their thrillers with a heavy dose of psychological depth and emotional resonance.
Note: While it can be read as a standalone, it is highly recommended to read The Butterfly Garden first to fully understand the history of the FBI team and the recurring characters who appear in this installment.
English (US) ·